Marginory

Etsy vs Amazon Handmade — Which Is Better for Sellers?

Compare Etsy and Amazon Handmade on fees, application requirements, discoverability, and profit per sale — for sellers deciding where to list handmade products.

By Marginory team · Online sellers with hands-on experience across Etsy, Shopify & PODUpdated Fee data verified against official platform documentation

Quick verdict (2026)

Choose Etsy if:

  • You want to start selling immediately, no approval
  • Your buyers actively search for "handmade" intent
  • You sell lower-priced items where Etsy's fee edge matters more

Choose Amazon Handmade if:

  • You can pass Amazon's handmade verification
  • You want access to Prime shipping and Amazon's logistics
  • Your products are higher-priced, where the flat 15% rate is simpler to plan around

Etsy vs Amazon Handmade — head-to-head comparison

FactorEtsyAmazon Handmade
Application requiredNo — open instantlyYes — verification of handmade status
Monthly feeNoneNone (waived for approved Handmade sellers)
Listing fee$0.20 per listingNone
Transaction/referral fee6.5%15% flat
Payment processing3% + $0.25 (included above)Included in 15% referral fee
Effective total on typical sale~9.5–10%15%
Fulfillment optionsSelf-fulfilled or your own 3PLSelf-fulfilled or FBA (Prime eligible)
Search intent matchVery high — buyers search for handmadeMixed — competes with mass-market listings

Fee comparison: $40 sale

Etsy

Sale price$40.00
Transaction fee (6.5%)−$2.60
Payment processing (3% + $0.25)−$1.45
Listing fee−$0.20
Total fees$4.25
10.6% effective rate

Amazon Handmade

Sale price$40.00
Referral fee (15% flat)−$6.00
Total fees$6.00
15.0% effective rate

At this price point, Etsy's fees run lower than Amazon Handmade's flat 15% rate. Etsy's advantage shrinks on very low-priced items (the fixed $0.25 processing fee and $0.20 listing fee matter more relatively) and stays roughly consistent as price increases, since both platforms scale primarily with a percentage of sale price.

Beyond fees: approval, traffic, and fulfillment

Fees aren't the only factor. Amazon Handmade requires an application and verification process that Etsy doesn't — you need to demonstrate your products are genuinely handmade, which can take days to weeks and isn't guaranteed. In exchange, approved sellers get access to Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) and Prime eligibility, which can meaningfully boost conversion for buyers who filter for Prime shipping. Etsy has no such barrier to entry but also no equivalent fulfillment network — sellers handle their own shipping or use a separate 3PL.

Etsy Fee Calculator →Etsy Profit Calculator →Etsy vs Shopify for Beginners →

Related Tools

Etsy Fee CalculatorEtsy Profit CalculatorEtsy vs Shopify for BeginnersHow Much Does Etsy Take

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Amazon Handmade cheaper than Etsy?
No — Amazon Handmade charges a flat 15% referral fee on most sales with no separate listing fee, while Etsy's effective rate is roughly 9.5–10% for a typical sale (6.5% transaction fee + 3% + $0.25 payment processing + $0.20 listing fee), before any Offsite Ads. On a $40 sale, Etsy fees run about $4.25 versus Amazon Handmade's flat $6.00.
Does Amazon Handmade have a monthly fee?
No monthly subscription fee for approved Handmade sellers — unlike Amazon's standard Professional selling plan ($39.99/month), Handmade sellers are exempt from the monthly fee and pay only the 15% referral fee per sale.
Is it harder to get approved for Amazon Handmade than to open an Etsy shop?
Yes, significantly. Etsy shops can be opened instantly with no approval process. Amazon Handmade requires an application reviewed by Amazon, including proof that products are genuinely handmade (not mass-manufactured or drop-shipped), and approval can take days to weeks — some applicants are rejected outright.
Which platform has more buyer traffic?
Amazon overall has vastly more total shoppers than Etsy, but Amazon Handmade is a smaller, less-discovered section within Amazon's marketplace — most Amazon shoppers default to standard search results, not the Handmade category specifically. Etsy's entire platform identity and search intent is built around handmade/craft goods, giving Handmade-specific sellers stronger discoverability per listing on Etsy despite Etsy's smaller overall traffic.
Can I sell on both Etsy and Amazon Handmade at the same time?
Yes, many sellers list the same products on both platforms to maximize reach. The tradeoff is managing two sets of listings, photos, and inventory sync, plus adapting to each platform's different fee structure and customer service expectations (Amazon has stricter, faster response-time requirements).