Printify vs Printful Profit - Compare Actual Quotes
Compare order and monthly profit with your actual product, shipping and subscription costs. No automatic winner or blanket discount.
By Marginory teamContent reviewed
Enter matching quotes for the same product specification, variant and delivery destination. The initial $12 product and $5 shipping inputs are illustrative budgets. No automatic subscription discount is assumed.
Printify
Use zero for Free. Annual equivalents are allocations, not monthly bills.
Printify results
Printful
Use zero for Free. Annual equivalents are allocations, not monthly bills.
Printful results
Printify Premium reference: $39/month or $299.88/year ($24.99/month allocation). Discounts depend on eligible product quotes. Include the plan-adjusted quote above and the subscription separately.
How this is calculated
Assumptions
- No tax, Offsite Ads, returns, advertising, packaging or labor in this comparison; add them to quotes or compare in the full profit tool.
- The comparison holds specification and demand assumptions equal. It does not rank product quality or forecast sales.
Source: printify.com/blog/new-printify-premium/ · Last verified: 2026-10-11
Worked example: cheaper quote vs fewer refunds
The same $30 shirt sold on Etsy with free shipping, using two quotes. The cheaper quote has a higher reprint/refund rate in this example.
| Provider A quote | Provider B quote | |
|---|---|---|
| Product + shipping | −$15.95 | −$19.49 |
| Etsy fees | −$3.30 | −$3.30 |
| Profit on a kept order | $10.75 | $7.21 |
| Refund rate | 3.0% | 1.5% |
| Average profit per order | $9.95 | $6.81 |
Refunds narrow the gap but rarely close a $3.54 quote difference on their own. Enter your own refund rates; they matter more on low-priced products.
Cost inputs are illustrative; fees are calculated with the same rates as the calculator above.
Use equivalent product specifications
Match material, size, print placements, personalization, destination and delivery method. A Bella+Canvas shirt and a different Gildan blank are not a controlled quality or price comparison. Defaults are hypothetical amounts; replace both with quotes for the product you intend to sell.
A complete cost comparison
Order contribution is seller revenue minus channel fees, quoted product cost, paid postage and per-order acquisition. Monthly profit multiplies order contribution by assumed volume and subtracts the provider plan. With no orders, a paid subscription remains a cost.
Worked quote difference
Hypothetical $30 sale with basic US Etsy fees of $3.30. Provider A quotes $12 product and $5 postage: contribution is $9.70. Provider B quotes $13 product and $4 postage: contribution is also $9.70. If A requires a $39 monthly plan for that quote, 20 orders contribute $194 before the plan and $155 after it. This example does not describe either provider's catalog.
Subscription discounts are eligibility-specific
Printify Premium currently lists $39 monthly or $299.88 annually; the annual allocation is about $24.99 per month. The advertised up-to discount is not a uniform percentage for every SKU. Printful Growth advertises product discounts subject to its plan rules. Enter the actual discounted quote and plan invoice so savings are not applied twice.
Price alone is not a provider verdict
Order samples and check printing, packing, tracking, replacement policy and support for the exact SKU. Delivery estimates are destination-specific and not a universal speed ranking. This calculator compares entered economics; it does not certify quality, fulfillment reliability or likely sales.
Sources and scope
Printify Premium pricing update. Printful plans. Confirm the account schedule and actual quote before pricing. The content review date does not verify every input or predict future results. How these estimates work.
Review the market, fee bases and exclusions shown with this tool. Published rates and illustrative cost inputs have different certainty. Compare your breakdown with an actual order statement. Sources and methodology.